Roblox Codex

Standard · Applies to every page

How Our Roblox Tier Lists Are Built — The Six Bands

Six bands with fixed meanings, two status words, and one rule that most sites skip: a table goes back to Draft every time the game patches.

Last checked 2026-11-18

Six bands, one meaning each

A tier list is only useful if two different writers would produce roughly the same list from the same game. That only happens when each band has a written definition instead of a feeling. These are ours, and they do not change from game to game.

S — changes how you play. The pick is strong enough that you build your account, your team, or your route around it. If you have it, the game is easier in a way other players notice.

A — safe to invest in. Strong in most situations with no obvious matchup that ruins it. Resources spent here are rarely wasted, even after a patch.

B — good, with a weakness. Works well until the game puts you against something specific, and then you have to play around it. Worth building if you already like the playstyle.

C — early game only. Useful while you are levelling or farming, replaced by something in A or S later. Fine to use, not worth heavy investment.

D — only if you already own it. Not worth chasing. If the game hands it to you, use it; do not spend resources to get it.

F — do not spend on it. Either outclassed by something you get for free, or actively bad at the thing it is supposed to do.

Why every table has a status word

Every tier table on this site is marked Draft or Checked, and the difference is the whole point.

  • Draft — the table is still being assembled. It may be incomplete and it should not be trusted as a ranking.
  • Checked — the writer has played the game since its most recent patch, and the bands reflect that patch.

A table drops from Checked back to Draft every time the game ships a balance patch, because a ranking written before a patch is a ranking of a different game. That rule costs us more work than it saves, which is why most sites do not use it.

How a table actually gets built

The process is boring on purpose:

  1. Play the current patch. Not a video of the current patch — the patch. Notes from someone else's session are how errors get copied.
  2. Test the picks that matter, not every pick. In most games a small number of options decide the outcome. Ranking the other forty is padding.
  3. Write the reason next to the band. A band with no reason is a guess. Every entry gets one line explaining what it does and what beats it.
  4. Date it and say which patch it matches. A table without a patch number is a table you cannot trust in three weeks.
  5. Re-check after every patch. This is the part nobody does, and the reason stale pages rank for months.

What our tier lists do not claim

They do not claim to be the community consensus. There is no such thing in a game that has been live for two weeks. They do not rank cosmetic items, and they do not rank anything we have not tested on the current patch.

They also do not account for your account. A pick that is S for a player with a full inventory can be D for someone on day one, and the table says so where it matters.

How to read a Draft table

If a page says Draft, use it for the structure — which questions the table will answer — and not for the answers. The redemption steps and the official links on the same page are usually fine, because they do not depend on balance.

If you think a band is wrong once a table is Checked, tell us the pick and the reason. A specific argument beats a complaint every time.

Questions players ask

What is the difference between Draft and Checked?

Draft means the table is still being assembled and should not be trusted as a ranking. Checked means the writer has played the game since its latest patch and the bands match that patch.

When does a table go back to Draft?

Every time the game ships a balance patch. A ranking written before a patch describes a different game, so it goes back to Draft until it is replayed.

Why does every entry have a written reason?

Because an unexplained band is just an opinion. Every entry carries one line saying what the pick does and what beats it, so you can disagree with the reasoning instead of the vibe.

Do the tables account for how new my account is?

Partly. A pick can be S for a full inventory and D on day one. Where that matters, the line says so.